Time to Propose: The Gentleman’s Guide to Pairing Your Engagement Ring with Your Watch

Your wristwear and your ring should tell one seamless story.

When you’re about to pop the question, every detail counts — especially your engagement ring. But if you’re already the kind of man who wears a watch that speaks volumes, why settle for a ring that doesn’t match that same level of style and thought?

At Fergus James, we know choosing the perfect engagement ring is about more than just the stone — it’s about pairing it perfectly with your signature watch to create a look that’s undeniably you.

Here’s how to select an engagement ring that not only wows your partner but also complements your personal style — from classic gold Datejust wearers to the boldest Submariner fans.

1. For the Classic Gentleman: Yellow Gold Datejust Meets Oval Solitaire

If your go-to is a Datejust with a champagne dial and that iconic Jubilee bracelet, your style is timeless and refined.

The perfect ring:

A yellow gold oval solitaire engagement ring. The oval shape mirrors the gentle curves of your watch case and bracelet links, while yellow gold ties directly into the warm tones on your wrist.

Why this works:

The Jubilee bracelet’s polished, rounded five-link design calls for a ring that’s elegant but not flashy. The oval cut’s elongated silhouette harmonises beautifully — it’s a subtle, sophisticated statement.

Pro tip: Ask for a brushed or matte finish on the band to balance shine and wearability. Low-set stones keep it practical for everyday life while looking effortlessly sleek.

2. Two-Tone Watch? Mix Your Metals

Sporting a two-tone watch? You clearly appreciate a bit of contrast.

Your match:

A marquise-cut diamond ring with a yellow gold band and white gold prongs.

Why it works:

The marquise cut’s pointed edges are striking, just like the bezel of your two-tone timepiece. White gold prongs keep your diamond icy and bright, while the yellow gold band echoes your watch’s warmth.

Gentleman’s tip:

Consider an east-west setting for a modern twist. It’s unexpected but perfectly balanced — just like your dual-metal watch.

3. For the Adventurer: Submariner + Brushed White Gold

If you wear a Submariner or any rugged steel sports watch, you know the value of durability mixed with style.

Your ideal ring:

A brushed white gold wedding band or a solitaire with a low-profile setting — subtle, strong, and designed to handle life’s adventures.

Why it fits:

Submariners are the quintessential tool watch. Your ring should match their blend of function and style. Matte finishes reduce scratches, and flush or bezel settings protect the stone without sacrificing elegance.

Fergus James insight:

Stay away from high-polish rings that show wear quickly. Instead, choose rings with texture or hidden sparkle for understated luxury.

4. The Bold Choice: Chocolate Dial + Rose Gold Accents

If your dial veers into rich chocolate territory (think Everose Rolex or Omega Sedna gold), rose gold jewellery is your soulmate. The tones play off each other naturally — warm, rich, and romantic.

For men:

Consider a rose gold wedding band with black diamond detailing. It’s a contemporary twist that matches a chocolate dial without feeling too coordinated.

For women:

Pair your dial with a blush-toned oval diamond or a soft pink sapphire — subtle yet unforgettable.

Power Couple’s pick:

Complete the look with matching rose gold tennis bracelets. For him — a black diamond bracelet with a single hidden white diamond. For her — classic white diamonds with one mysterious black stone nestled inside, both set in 18K Rose Gold.

Why it works:

Rose gold complements deeper dial hues beautifully, while black diamonds add masculine edge and dimension. The matching bracelets create a modern heirloom vibe — classic yet playful, understated yet symbolic.

Honourable Mentions:

• Explorer II + Black Diamonds:
  A brushed white gold band with a channel of black diamonds works perfectly with the rugged adventurer’s dial.

• Cartier Santos + Clean Lines:
  Pair with a bezel-set diamond eternity ring or minimalist baguette band — architectural and iconic.

• Iced-Out AP + Pavé:
  If your watch is already doing the most, lean into it. A fully pavé wedding band or chunky Cuban-style diamond bracelet turns up the volume.

You Don’t Wear Time. You Wear Taste.

At Fergus James, your engagement ring is more than a symbol — it’s a statement. One that complements your watch, fits your lifestyle, and tells your story.

Ready to design the perfect ring to match your wrist and your style? Let’s get started